Exchange 2016 CU6: Behavior Change in Item Recovery
Cumulative Update 6 (CU6) for Exchange Server 2016 will be released soonTM, but before that happens, I wanted to make you aware of a behavior change in item recovery that is shipping in CU6. Hopefully this information will aid you in your planning, testing, and deployment of CU6.
Prior to Exchange 2010, we had the Dumpster 1.0, which was essentially a view stored per folder. Items in the dumpster stayed in the folder where they were soft-deleted (shift-delete or delete from Deleted Items) and were stamped with the ptagDeletedOnFlag flag. These items were special-cased in the store to be excluded from normal Outlook views and quotas. This design also meant that when a user wanted to recover the item, it was restored to its original folder.
With Exchange 2010, we moved away from Dumpster 1.0 and replaced it with the Recoverable Items folder. I discussed the details of that architectural shift in the article, Single Item Recovery in Exchange 2010. The Recoverable Items architecture created several benefits: deleted items moved with the mailbox, deleted items were indexable and discoverable, and facilitated both short-term and long-term data preservation scenarios.
As a reminder, the following actions can be performed by a user:
- A user can perform a soft-delete operation where the item is deleted from an Inbox folder and moved to the Deleted Items folder. The Deleted Items folder can be emptied either manually by the user, or automatically via a Retention Policy. When data is removed from the Deleted Items folder, it is placed in the Recoverable Items\Deletions folder.
- A user can perform a hard-delete operation where the item is deleted from an Inbox folder and moved to the Recoverable Items\Deletions folder, bypassing the Deleted Items folder entirely.
- A user can recover items stored in the Recoverable Items\Deletions folder via recovery options in Outlook for Windows and Outlook on the web.
- However, this architecture has a drawback – items cannot be recovered to their original folders.
Many of you have voiced your concerns around this limitation in the Recoverable Items architecture, through various feedback mechanisms, like at Ignite 2015 in Chicago where we had a panel that included the Mailbox Intelligence team (those who own backup, HA, DR, search, etc.). Due to your overwhelming feedback, I am pleased to announce that beginning with Exchange 2016 CU6, items can be recovered to their original folders!
How does it work?
- When an item is deleted (soft-delete or hard-delete) it is stamped with the LastActiveParentEntryID (LAPEID). By using the folder ID, it does not matter if the folder is moved in the mailbox’s hierarchy or renamed.
- When the user attempts a recovery action, the LAPEID is used as the move destination endpoint.
The LAPEID stamping mechanism has been in place since Exchange 2016 Cumulative Update 1. This means that as soon as you install CU6, your users can recover items to their original folders!
Are there limitations?
Yes, there are limitations.
First, to use this functionality, the user’s mailbox must be on a Mailbox server that has CU6 installed. The user must also use Outlook on the web to recover to the original folder; neither Outlook for Windows or Outlook for Mac support this functionality, today.
If an item does not have an LAPEID stamped, then the item will be recovered to its folder type origin – Inbox for mail items, Calendar for calendar items, Contacts for contact items, and Tasks for task items. How could an item not have an LAPEID? Well, if the item was deleted before CU1 was installed, it won’t have an LAPEID.
And lastly, this feature does not recover deleted folders. It only recovers items to folders that still exist within the user’s mailbox hierarchy. Once a folder is deleted, recovery will be to the folder type origin for that item.